The reporting quality of randomised controlled trials in surgery: A systematic review.

The reporting quality of randomised controlled trials in surgery: A systematic review. Research Abstract Details 

Research Abstract Table of Contents

Jump to the:

The reporting quality of randomised controlled trials in surgery: A systematic review. Abstract Text:

Riaz Agha,Derek Cooper,Gordon Muir,Riaz Agha,Derek Cooper,Gordon Muir,Riaz Agha,Derek Cooper,Gordon Muir,

OBJECTIVES: In order to examine the reporting quality of urological RCTs, the initial objectives of this study were to evaluate the degree to which RCTs involving urological surgical techniques (as the intervention) published in the years 2000-2003 complied with the CONSORT statement, and to assess trends and patterns of compliance. Following our initial findings in urology, we extended the methodology to a number of other specialties to assess whether our findings in urology could be generalised to other surgical disciplines. METHODS: The Royal Society of Medicine (RSM) Library was commissioned to search the Medline and Cochrane databases for RCTs in compliance with the study inclusion criteria below. Additional analyses of five other specialties (non-urological trials: cardiovascular, gastrointestinal, hepatic, orthopaedic and vascular) were also made. For the non-urological trials, 15 English language trials (from each specialty) were randomly picked from a blast search conducted by the RSM for the year 2003. The RCTs were given a score out of 22, reflecting how many of the 22 CONSORT items were complied with (with each item being given equal weighting), this score was termed the "CONSORT score". RESULTS: Urology trials: In total 122 RCT abstracts were identified which met the inclusion criteria for this study. From these, 32 were excluded as they were follow-up studies, involved a virtual procedure or were a cost analysis, leaving 90 RCTs published across 35 different journals which were analysed (68.2%, 90/122). The average score of 11.1 for urological trials indicates that RCTs in our sample do not comply with the CONSORT statement. No trials reported how they implemented their randomisation process. Only 46% of RCTs stated that they had permission from an ethics review board, 20% had declared their sources of funding, 14% stated whether there were any conflicts of interest and only 1.1% stated their trial registry number. For non-urological studies, an average CONSORT score of 11.2 was obtained. CONCLUSION: Clinical research teams conducting RCTs in urology and other surgical disciplines demonstrate poor compliance with the CONSORT statement. We would recommend that trials should be registered at their outset and that urological and other surgical journals to consider supporting the CONSORT statement and to have compliance 'hard-wired' into their submission, editorial and peer-review processes. Since it seems the best researchers are unable to produce an RCT results which enable surgical techniques to be critically assessed, there is a need for education about the CONSORT statement and its importance at all levels of surgical training. We believe that an open debate is needed on the possible role of other research designs, such as tracker studies. Whether this study actually raises the question of how appropriate RCTs are to surgical techniques, we leave to the reader.

The reporting quality of randomised controlled trials in surgery: A systematic review. Publishing Authors By Initials

R Agha,D Cooper,G Muir,R Agha,D Cooper,G Muir,R Agha,D Cooper,G Muir,

For similar abstracts research abstracts see: abstracts research

PUBMED ID PMID:

MEDLINE DATE:

The reporting quality of randomised controlled trials in surgery: A systematic review. Journal Published:

PUBLICATION TYPE: Journal Article

Journal: International journal of surgery (London, England)

VOLUME: 5

Page Numbers: 413-22

Journal Abbreviation:

ISSN: 1743-9159

DAY: 29

MONTH: 10

YEAR: 2007

The reporting quality of randomised controlled trials in surgery: A systematic review. Information

Number of References:

LANGUAGE: eng

NlmUniqueID: 101228232

The reporting quality of randomised controlled trials in surgery: A systematic review. Keywords Mesh Terms:

KEYWORDS:

MESH TERMS:

Chemical & Substance for Abstract: The reporting quality of randomised controlled trials in surgery: A systematic review. Information

Substance Name:

Registry Number:

Grant and Affiliation Information for The reporting quality of randomised controlled trials in surgery: A systematic review.

AFFILIATION: International Journal of Surgery, Surgical Associates Ltd, 167 Earls Court Road, London SW5 9RF, UK; King's College London, UK.

Country: England

AGENCY:

GRANT:

ACRONYM:

MEDLINETA: Int J Surg

REFSOURCE:

DATABASENAME:

ACCESSION NUMBER:

Number Hits: 0

The reporting quality of randomised controlled trials in surgery: A systematic review Related Publications

• ;Quantal' Ca2+ release at the cytoplasmic aspect of the Ins(1,4,5)P3R channel in smooth muscle.
• A case of carcinoma of the duodenum.
• An orthotopic xenograft model of intraneural NF1 MPNST suggests a potential association between steroid hormones and tumor cell proliferation.
• Aspirin and folic acid for the prevention of recurrent colorectal adenomas.
• Asynchrony and cyclic variability in pressure support noninvasive ventilation.
• Auxiliary-mediated site-specific peptide ubiquitylation.
• Carbohydrate metabolism and gastric secretory activity.
• Chondroitinase applied to peripheral nerve repair averts retrograde axonal regeneration.
• Chondroitinase treatment increases the effective length of acellular nerve grafts.
• Comparison of genomic and traditional BLUP-estimated breeding value accuracy and selection response under alternative trait and genomic parameters.
• Continuous cardiac output monitoring via arterial pressure waveform analysis following severe hemorrhagic shock in dogs.
• Covalent capture of phospho-dependent protein oligomerization by site-specific incorporation of a diazirine photo-cross-linker.
• Global fate of POPs: Current and future research directions.
• Molecular mechanisms of agr quorum sensing in virulent staphylococci.
• Morphologic changes associated with functional adaptation of the navicular bone of horses.
• Periodic painful purpura: Fact or factitious?
• Photoselective vaporization of the prostate (GreenLight PV): lessons learnt after 3500 procedures.
• Plexiform-like neurofibromas develop in the mouse by intraneural xenograft of an NF1 tumor-derived Schwann cell line.
• Post-translational enzyme activation in an animal via optimized conditional protein splicing.
• Protein splicing triggered by a small molecule.
• Recurrence plots for dynamical analysis of non-invasive mechanical ventilation.
• Schizotypal cognitions as a predictor of psychopathology in adolescents with mild intellectual impairment.
• Severity of Clostridium difficile-associated diarrhea in solid organ transplant patients.
• Small-molecule-mediated rescue of protein function by an inducible proteolytic shunt.
• Structural and functional consequences of an amide-to-ester substitution in the selectivity filter of a potassium channel.
• Synthesis of fluorescein-labelled O-mannosylated peptides as components for synthetic vaccines: comparison of two synthetic strategies.
• The reporting quality of randomised controlled trials in surgery: A systematic review.
• Thymidylate synthase polymorphisms, folate and B-vitamin intake, and risk of colorectal adenoma.
• [In Process Citation]
• [In Process Citation]