An evaluation of 'confirmatory' medical opinion given to English courts in 14 cases of alleged child sexual abuse.

An evaluation of 'confirmatory' medical opinion given to English courts in 14 cases of alleged child sexual abuse. Research Abstract Details 

Research Abstract Table of Contents

Jump to the:

An evaluation of 'confirmatory' medical opinion given to English courts in 14 cases of alleged child sexual abuse. Abstract Text:

Mary Pillai,Mary Pillai,Mary Pillai,

Fourteen cases of alleged child sexual abuse, where the medical opinion rated a high degree of concordance with the history or suspicion of abuse given to the doctor, were reviewed to evaluate the objectivity and reliability of the medical evidence. It was common practice for physicians conducting the medical examination to form conclusions that the child had been sexually abused on the basis of the examiner's willingness to accept statements by the child, the adolescent, the caregiver or the investigator without determining if this information was accurate and obtained through the use of appropriate interviewing techniques. In the prepubertal children, evaluation of the examination findings revealed anatomical descriptions that were normal or non-specific, rather than supportive of abuse. In the teenagers, inadequate consideration was made of the behavioural and physical differences that occur with adolescence. The physical findings were not interpreted using research derived knowledge concerning the variations of "normal" and the particular conditions that may be mistaken as abuse. The medical reports of these examinations suggest to this author a possibility of the significance and relevance of physical findings being unduly and unwittingly over-emphasised, despite the cases all having occurred post the Cleveland Inquiry [Butler Sloss E. Report into the Child Abuse Enquiry in Cleveland, 1987. London, HMSO] and some as recently as 2005. This may reflect emotional involvement in the case and the doctor taking on a role of advocacy for the child. It is sometimes difficult for physicians to step out of the medical role where they do have the responsibility to diagnose and into a role where their information is only a piece of the puzzle and it is the work of the court to determine if sexual abuse has occurred. The role confusion between medicine and forensics must be sorted out in order for physicians to provide an objective assessment. The main conclusion of this paper is that it identifies significant training needs among doctors undertaking child examinations for suspected sexual abuse.

An evaluation of 'confirmatory' medical opinion given to English courts in 14 cases of alleged child sexual abuse. Publishing Authors By Initials

M Pillai,M Pillai,M Pillai,

For similar abstracts research abstracts see: abstracts research

PUBMED ID PMID:

MEDLINE DATE:

An evaluation of 'confirmatory' medical opinion given to English courts in 14 cases of alleged child sexual abuse. Journal Published:

PUBLICATION TYPE: Journal Article

Journal: Journal of forensic and legal medicine

VOLUME: 14

Page Numbers: 503-14

Journal Abbreviation:

ISSN: 1752-928X

DAY: 28

MONTH: 03

YEAR: 2007

An evaluation of 'confirmatory' medical opinion given to English courts in 14 cases of alleged child sexual abuse. Information

Number of References:

LANGUAGE: eng

NlmUniqueID: 101300022

An evaluation of 'confirmatory' medical opinion given to English courts in 14 cases of alleged child sexual abuse. Keywords Mesh Terms:

KEYWORDS:

MESH TERMS:

Chemical & Substance for Abstract: An evaluation of 'confirmatory' medical opinion given to English courts in 14 cases of alleged child sexual abuse. Information

Substance Name:

Registry Number:

Grant and Affiliation Information for An evaluation of 'confirmatory' medical opinion given to English courts in 14 cases of alleged child sexual abuse.

AFFILIATION: Cheltenham General Hospital, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Sandford Road, Cheltenham GL53 7AN, United Kingdom.

Country: England

AGENCY:

GRANT:

ACRONYM:

MEDLINETA: J Forensic Leg Med

REFSOURCE:

DATABASENAME:

ACCESSION NUMBER:

Number Hits: 0

An evaluation of 'confirmatory' medical opinion given to English courts in 14 cases of alleged child sexual abuse Related Publications

• A CASE OF FILARIASIS OCULI.
• A microfluidic device for continuous capture and concentration of microorganisms from potable water.
• A role for voltage-dependent anion channel vdac1 in polyglutamine-mediated neuronal cell death.
• An evaluation of 'confirmatory' medical opinion given to English courts in 14 cases of alleged child sexual abuse.
• Biology of PPARgamma in cancer: a critical review on existing lacunae.
• Brain-Derived Neurotropic Factor/TrkB Signaling in the Pathogenesis and Novel Pharmacotherapy of Schizophrenia.
• Comparative study of the shape-dependent electrocatalytic activity of platinum multipods, discs, and hexagons: applications for fuel cells.
• Decreased expression of Sprouty2 in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in schizophrenia and bipolar disorder: a correlation with BDNF expression.
• Development of an electrochemical (90)Sr-(90)Y generator for separation of (90)Y suitable for targeted therapy.
• Early relapse risk after a first CNS inflammatory demyelination episode: examining international consensus definitions.
• Effect of chronic chromium picolinate in animal models of anxiety and memory.
• Facilitating the Canadian rule.
• Further Studies on Antioxidant Potential and Protection of Pancreatic beta-Cells by Embelia ribes in Experimental Diabetes.
• Identification of ground beef-derived fatty acid inhibitors of autoinducer-2-based cell signaling.
• Identification of poultry meat-derived fatty acids functioning as quorum sensing signal inhibitors to autoinducer-2 (AI-2).
• In vitro activity of azithromycin, newer quinolones and cephalosporins in ciprofloxacin-resistant Salmonella causing enteric fever.
• Inferring HIV Transmission Dynamics from Phylogenetic Sequence Relationships.
• Invited commentary.
• Lecithin from Mucuna pruriens.
• Medicine and the state.
• Museums of the United States of America.
• Naive recirculating B cells mature simultaneously in the spleen and bone marrow.
• Polymorphisms in the endothelin-1 (EDN1) are associated with asthma in two populations.
• Proteomic Analysis to Identify the Role of LuxS/AI-2 Mediated Protein Expression in Escherichia coli O157:H7.
• Radiosensitizing effects of plumbagin in cervical cancer cells is through modulation of apoptotic pathway.
• Screening of hepatoprotective effect of a herbal mixture against CCl4 induced hepatotoxicity in Swiss albino mice.
• Synergism between NF-kappa B1/p50 and Notch2 during the development of marginal zone B lymphocytes.
• The recirculating B cell pool contains two functionally distinct, long-lived, posttransitional, follicular B cell populations.
• Unique program in Antigua; stores distribute supplies.
• Zeta potential of selected bacteria in drinking water when dead, starved, or exposed to minimal and rich culture media.