Go Back   Science Forums Biology Forum Molecular Biology Forum Physics Chemistry Forum > Molecular Research Topics Forum > Animal and Molecular Model Systems > Arabidopsis and Plant Biology
Register Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Arabidopsis and Plant Biology Discuss Arabidopsis and Plant Biology Research.


Common name capital 'A' or small 'a'?

Common name capital 'A' or small 'a'? - Arabidopsis and Plant Biology

Common name capital 'A' or small 'a'? - Discuss Arabidopsis and Plant Biology Research.


Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 09-06-2006, 05:21 AM
chrday@gmail.com
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Common name capital 'A' or small 'a'?



Is there any official policy with respect to using Arabidopsis (no
italics) compared to arabidopsis (no italics)? It appears that the
'capital A' is favoured but i have seen the 'small a' too.

The plant physiology guidelines do confirm that the genus can be used
as a common name. So arabidopsis can be written in a no italics form,
however, they are ambiguous about the use of the 'capital A' or 'small
a' since their only use of arabidopsis is at the start of a sentence.
"Common names can be used after first mention. Arabidopsis (no italics)
is an accepted common name for A. thaliana." from
[Only registered users see links. ]

Tobias Baskin wrote a short piece on this news group in the 90's:
[Only registered users see links. ]


[Start quote]
There are two different issues, one is italics, the other is
capitalization. The rule for capitalization is very simple: the genus
name is always capitalized and the species name is never capitalized.
No one has any problem with this in writing binomials. But for some
reason a habit has developed to retain the capital when the genus name
gets used as a common name for the species. In writing "this
breathtaking Arabidopsis mutant", the word "Arabidopsis" is being used
as the common name, like pea or wheat for those species, and not to
refer to the genus, Arabidopsis, and so should not be capitalized.
Despite the fact that this habit totally violates a long standing rule
of taxonomy, it has become so ingrained that many editors and journals
INSIST on the capital. I don't know why this habit started, (laziness?)
but the same has happend for drosophila and xenopus, among others, and
I don't think at this point that anything can be done.
[End Quote]

And in 1994 Plant Molecular Biology Reporter (12(4):300-301) also
endorsed using a small a:

[Start Quote]
Anyone exposed to introductory biology knows that Latin binomials are
italicized, the first letter of the genus capitalized and the species
lower case: Escherichia coli, Drosophila melanogaster, Arabidopsis
thaliana (all three italicised). We find increasingly in scientific
journals, however, the unitalicized terms "Drosophila" or
"Arabidopsis." It is clear from the context that writers are not
referring to the genus as a whole, but to their familiar species, D.
melanogaster or A. thaliana. What is happening?

The favorite weed of molecular biologists has become so commonplace in
science writing that the Latin formalism can be discarded. "A.
thaliana" doesn't roll off the tongue as smoothly as "E. coli," so
"arabidopsis" has simply been incorporated into ordinary English--at
least, ordinary scientific English.

Other than for taxonomy, the rule is that foreign words are italicized
in English: Weltanschauung, de gustibus, nom de plume (all three
italicised). There is ample precedent, however, for the incorporation
of foreign words into English, whereupon italics melt into plain roman:
alter ego, chic, honcho, pizza, siesta, troika.

We need not look beyond the world of plants for more examples: Starting
with A, we have abelia, acacia, agapanthus, ajuga, aloe, alyssum,
amaranthus, amaryllis, anemone, aster. Each of these flowers are known
by ordinary English words, each borrowed from the genus, and each
familiar to every gardener. All English speakers are equally familiar
with gladiolus, iris, and zinnia. Scientists (and most gardeners) know,
however, that a reference to genus and species still gets the full
treatment: as in Gladiolus nanus, Iris danfordiae, and Zinnia elegans
(all three italicised).

It is equally appropriate, therefore, to write "petunia" or "Petunia
hybrida (italicised)" but note that "petunia" in ordinary English is
in lower case; it is not "Petunia."

Welcoming our favorite weed into scientific English, the REPORTER
henceforth will print its name as "arabidopsis." On the advice of our
consultant in Greek, we offer no recommendations on its pronunciation.
[End Quote]

Lastly, reading the international code of botanical nomenclature (ICBN)
principles it is clear that they recommend that common names such as
arabidopsis use a small first letter.

So what is the current status, small a or big A? Is use of the capital
A just laztness, as Tobias suggested, or is this now standard practice?

Thanks for any pointers.

Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 09-08-2006, 02:39 PM
Terry Delaney
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Common name capital 'A' or small 'a'?

Dear chrday,

Thanks for your note and for posting the earlier comments from Tobias
Baskin and the PMBR. I have felt awkward in our past writings to use
Arabidopsis as the common name for A. thaliana, so was happy to read
some thoughtful commentary on the issue. I also talked to a seasoned
systemicist in my department who said that Baskin was exactly correct
in his view that arabidopsis should not be capitalized. So, I will no
longer feel awkward and use arabidopsis as the common name, and
hopefully journal editors will agree to a common treatment of this
issue.

Best regards, -Terry Delaney
The University of Vermont

[Only registered users see links. ] wrote:

Reply With Quote
Reply

Tags
capital , common , small


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Natural selection is proven wrong gim Biology Forum 3 05-15-2009 07:43 PM
qPCR NEWS - small activating RNA (saRNA) Editor www.Gene-Quantification.info Protocols and Methods Forum 0 02-26-2008 12:30 PM
Politics And Cannibalism? Introducing The Dourties, Chelsea, Bill, Hillary, Barrack Obama, George Bush, Jr., And All Of Capital Hill! jon_johnfrancisayres@yahoo.com Microbiology Forum 0 10-06-2007 05:59 AM


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:02 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 2005 - 2012 Molecular Station | All Rights Reserved
Page generated in 0.15309 seconds with 16 queries